URBAN DECAY24/7 Waterproof Waterline Eyeliner Pencil, Smudge-Resistant, Transfer-Resistant, 24HR Wear, Long-lasting Creamy Neutral Color, Eye Liner for Tightlining + Defining, Vegan - 0.04 oz

This eye liner is terrific! First, it goes on smooth— no tugging of skin. Second, it creates a definite line, (which can also be smudged, if you like), that stays put all day. No reapplication needed at all. Third, comes off easily with soap and water. Finally— the color is outstanding. I have green eyes and this grey liner is perfecto! Highly recommend.

I love this liner. I have several colors. But this one is the perfect black, stays in the waterline and doesn’t flake or smudge. Lasts until I remove my makeup!

I use this for my upper lid waterline and I have to say that it never came off! Maybe a little showed on the lower lid when I initially used it but I wiped it away and had no problem after that! IT really stays! I thought it was very pricey but is well worth it if it will last more than an hour and this certainly does last much longer. In fact when I took my shower at night I really had to wash my eyes twice to get most of it off and to be honest with you that makes me very happy!

Does Urban Decay have to make this pencil so expensive?? It seems to work, though. But sharpening the pencil was very, very difficult!! There is no pencil sharpener that works with this pencil. The only one I found after much experimentation was "Sun's Out pencil sharpener" on the advice of another reviewer here. It seems to work well, but I think Urban Decay should make it easier by making a sharpener specifically for the pencil or at least address how to sharpen it.

I love this product because it's waterproof and the pigment in Black is really good, but you have to sharpen it all the time if you use a lot! It has a genuine long length, thoughwhich in the long run helps! P.S. glides on nicely also!

Don’t waste your money does not come with a sharpener and when I finally did sharpen it, some of the wood splinters went into my eye. Horrible product. Do not recommend esp for the heafty price.

Very good product. Wider point. Wears well. Good for more brows.

I love the color. The eyeliner pencil came in with a broken tip. The liner itself is soft and smudges. I did not return hoping to use the pencil. Will not buy again.