Ultimate Guard Supreme Oversize Card Sleeves (40 Piece), Black

Never thought they'd make sleeves for these oversized cards; finally, my old MTG schemes are safe. Perfect fit and qualitatively identical to any other sleeve out there.

These sleeves work great with oversized Magic: The Gathering cards like those found in Commander decks or the Planechase Anthology. They are top loading sleeves like you typically find for standard sized cards. I bought three packs to sleeve my planar cards from the Planechase Anthology. They definitely add some bulk so you shouldn't expect to fit the cards back in the box when you are done sleeving. The shuffle feel is good and the cards stay neatly stacked on your playing surface (i.e. they aren't too slippery).

Great for what they do. Protect better than the side loading ones because they top load. But really, you only use them in a few situations: Commander cards that come in Commander pre-made decks and Scheme cards in Archenemy. 40 is a lot. You should only really need 2 for Archenemy and the few large Commander cards you get, unless you are a hardcore collector.

There aren't a whole lot of options for sleeves for the oversized commander cards for Magic: The Gathering, and these are great sleeves. Just not the sturdiest sleeves in the world. They hold up well, but not outstandingly so. The best part is, even though they're not the surdiest, you only ever need one st a time, so a pack likely lasts a long time.

I chose these sleeves over the sideloading ones because side-loading sleeves just don't make sense to use; they're looser and don't protect the cards as well since there's a wider opening. I bought these for my Planechase cards and oversized Commander cards and they fit perfectly. The sleeves themselves are good quality and shuffle well. Would definitely buy these again if I ever needed more.

This card sleeves fit just fine for my card game. With just a tiny bit of extra room at the top.

If you have the planechase anthology you will need 3 packs to sleeve them all.

These sleeves fit those cards very well but they have opaque black backs. That doesn't bother me. They can be shuffled pretty well when in the sleeves too.